.... my boss thinks I'm some sort of throwback.
Talk about the perfect set-up, Mainy... We all think you're a throw-back.
That JJJ list was a perfect reflection of the voter age. While Smells Like Teen Spirit is a great song well deserved of being in any top 100, being voted the greatest record of all time is a bit of a stretch. It doesn't take much thought to think of 10 songs that had more musical innovation, sociological impact, and a great unforgettable groove than 'Teen Spirit.
I mostly agree, actually - but the point of the Hottest 100 is that its not about the technically best songs or anything like that - its about people voting for stuff that they like without needing to justfy it. Plenty of the punters that they called up, had actually voted for 'shockers' (by JJJ standards) for at least some of their choices.
So the Hottest 100 is actually the "Hottest 100 as voted by JJJ listeners in June 2009" - which is kinda what I was vaguely alluding to in my previous post. The youngsters do dominate the voting, and yet they can't get one of "their" songs into the Top 10. The list in another 10 years will be interesting - once the songs of the last ten years have had time to 'age' and be judged for their overall merit and/or historical significance.
I cannot think of any recent songs that I know will rate highly in the 2019 list, although I predicted at least half of the top 20.
Teen Spirit is THE anthem of Gen X, for better or for worse - as someone else said recently, "Nirvana was the band that finally killed 80s music". They're a long way from the top of my list, but the release of Nirvana's Nevermind was clearly a pivotal moment in recent musical history - and consequently its in the same "culturally signficant" ball-park as any Dylan/Stones/Beatles songs
ever were - and arguably more significant
at this point in history.
Teen Spirit isn't my favourite Nirvana song, or even my favourite song from that album - but it is still the iconic song that everyone of roughly my age thinks of when they talk about good music.