A few thoughts that I can't be bothered turning into an otherwise coherent post:
1. Internet forums like these have removed a lot of the social aspect of Club Meetings.
2. As Clubs are run more like businesses, members expect to be provided with a service (as a customer does). This quickly damages/destroys the idea of a "club" and (in particular) reduces the general membership's willingness to help in the running of the club.
If members feel that they gain value from joining/renewing then that helps heaps. Similarly, if members feel that their contribution to the club is worthwhile, then they are far more likely to offer that contribution.
3. Virtually nobody has any spare time. And even the die-hards usually have past-times away from the club. Every club then stuggles to find people who can commit to making anything happen.
4. Everything goes in cycles. I have been heavily involved in two car clubs - ten years ago, one of them was just existing. Now, that same club is progressive and innovative and has a sparkling reputation.
In the same time, the other club has become very financially successful but suffers from incredible apathy within the membership and a reputation for in-house bickering, and for being petty and mean spirited. While it is still easily the larger club, the trend for the memberships is as you'd expect.
5a. Personal agendas are very difficult to manage - it only takes one person in a position of influence within the club to turn lots of people away (even if they maintain their membership).
The fortunes of my two car clubs can be directly linked to the level of influnce of particular people within each club.
5b. The number of memberships has only a passing relationship with the club's real value.
6. At the Retro-MX ride yesterday, the overwhleming vibe was that we were all a part of making something happen, and the sense of community was palpable. This is a relatively easy feeling to achieve in the early days of any club, before the nuts and bolts of running the club becomes apparent, but it is all too rare in many clubs nowdays.
7. The requirement to have 'qualified' officials tends to create an atmosphere of "us and them" within clubs - it creates a hurdle (real or imagined) between the majority of the membership and the people that actually, directly make events happen. This is then compounded when the qualified people are flogged to death and everyone else sort of sits back and thinks "I dont want to get qualified because it means you get flogged to death!"...