some more pictures. I discovered that it was magnesium when I would weld an injury, I have welded aluminum for 20 years so I can see the man differs from aluminum and magnesium
It does look like Mag.
Magnesium castings and aluminium castings are like chalk & cheese.
You can lay a bead of alloy rod onto a Mag casting that may look okay but it actually crystallizes at the join and as you say, with a pair of pliers you can pull the weld bead away from the casting.
Using another piece of Mag from something else to fill the hole is a good move but a waste of time if you used alloy filler rod, you would have needed to use a special Magnesium rod for it to be successful.
Magnesium castings also needs lower amps as it has a lower melting point compared to Aluminium and the Mag castings also welds a bit ‘fluffy’