Author Topic: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?  (Read 2307 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline brent j

  • Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 1435
  • Darwin, NT. Suzuki tragic, RL250M TS90MX PE250B
    • View Profile
Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« on: April 20, 2009, 09:36:32 am »
A question for the electrically minded.

Can I run an XT/TT coil (single wire) with an SR CDI? (2 wire coil)
I'm running an SR ignition on my XT and I need a smaller coil. I don't have an SR coil but I'm using a larger coil off a later Yamaha.

Looking at a wiring diagram I see that the SR has a power wire running to the coil and an earth going back to the CDI.
There is a separate wire from the CDI for the kill switch and ignition switch.
Is the earth wire on the SR coil separate to the earth on the mount or connected internally.
I’m wondering if I can run an XT coil and run the earth wire from the CDI to the mount on the coil therefore completing the earth circuit?

Why? I went to fit my standard XT tank to my bike for a long trail ride
(I usually run a YZ125C tank) and I could not get the tank to fit over the larger coil I am running (off a later Yamaha). I need a suitable coil that will fit on the original mount. There is not really a lot of space under an XT tank.

Thanks in advance for any help

Brent
« Last Edit: April 20, 2009, 11:50:06 am by brent j »
The older I get, the faster I was

Offline caps 999

  • Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 1762
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #1 on: April 20, 2009, 09:44:25 am »
i think you can as long as your run an earth back to your cdi
MUGEN power

Offline curly001

  • B-Grade
  • ***
  • Posts: 264
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #2 on: April 20, 2009, 01:38:32 pm »
Brent have been running an XT coil with the SR cdi for over 2 years no problems. As for the Kill switch wiring will need to look at how I wired it up, am using YZ kill switch. Curly

Offline brent j

  • Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 1435
  • Darwin, NT. Suzuki tragic, RL250M TS90MX PE250B
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #3 on: April 21, 2009, 01:41:31 pm »
Curly from the XT forum I presume????

What year is your XT? I'm wondering about the early type coil.

Now I think about it, the XT points coil is 6v and the SR CDI system is 12 volt, same as the late XT's

More and more confusing.

Brent
The older I get, the faster I was

Offline Colin Jay

  • Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 519
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #4 on: April 21, 2009, 08:48:39 pm »
Brent, you are correct in stating that the XT (points ignition) coil is a 6V coil and the SR (CDI) coil is a 12V coil. These voltages are nominal voltages as the ignition source coils can put out significantly higher voltages as the revs increase.

From my workshop manuals;

The XT coil has a primary resistance of 0.75 ohms and a secondary resistance of 5,700 ohms.

The SR coil  has a primary resistance of 0.98 ohms and a secondary resistance of 12,000 ohms.

These resistances don't mean a great deal in themselves as different diameter wire will have different value of resistivity and the two coils could still have similar turns ratios. It is the turns ratio that give the increase of voltage from the primary voltage (6 or 12 volts) up to the secondary voltage required to "spark" the spark plug. For example, if the coils had a 1:1000 ratio, 6 volts on the primary would give you 6,000 volts at the seconday / sparkplug and 12v would give 12,000 volts. Normally you would be looking at getting a secondary voltage some were in the order of 20,000 volts or more to give a good spark at the plug, so the turns ratio would probably be more than 1:1000, however the increase in primary voltage as the revs rise could easily give well over 20,000 volts at the top end of the rev range even with a 1:1000 turns ratio.

The main concern with using an XT (6V) coil on a SR (12V) ignition system would be the current (amps) drawn by the coil. Ohm's Law, one of the major laws of electricity, states that in a purely resistive circuit;

 Current (amps) = Voltage / Resistance

So, discounting inductive reactance and a few other finer points of electrical theory, the current drawn by the XT coil would be (6 volts / 0.75 ohms) 8 amps when suppied by the XT source coil.

The current drawn by the XT coil if supplied with the 12 volts from the SR ignition source coil would be double that drawn when supplied from the XT source coil, i.e, 12 volts / 0.75 ohms = 16 amps.

This doubling of the amount of current drawn by the coil would as a minimum cause the coil to run hot, in a worst case it would cause the coil to burn out as the coil would have been wound with wire to suit the nominal maximum current draw of 8 amps.

Now all the above is just very basic theory, and like every thing in life, some times thing will work that just defy the theories that they are built upon, so you could probably fit the XT coil to the SR ignition and never have a problem with it. That is until you are somewhere down along the Tanami Track, because then Murphy's Law will overide everthing!

To get away from the electrical theory, I have a complete SR electrical system fitted to the XT500's that I ride in road trials here in SA. I am running the STD SR ignition coil even though it will not fit into the mounting brackets welded to the frame for the XT ignition coil. Like all good electricians I have held the coil in place with a couple of cable ties, and had no problems. Last year the XT was ridden in 2 x 6hr events, 1 x 8hr event, for 13hr in the 24hr and for about 1500km of road use without any problem with the cable ties, so although its not the best solution, it has worked well enough for me to cable tie the coil inplace on the years bike as well. The std XT fuel tank fits without rubbing on the coil, although it did take a bit of dicking around initially to get the coil into a position where it didn't touch the tank.

An option might be to check out some of the aftermarket universal ignition coils, you might find that you can get a coil suitable for use with a CDI that will fit into the std coil brackets. I know that the universal "points ignition" coils fit as I have one fitted to my TT500.

CJ



Why do things the easy way, when with a bit of effort you can really make it difficult for yourself!!

Offline curly001

  • B-Grade
  • ***
  • Posts: 264
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #5 on: April 22, 2009, 04:42:40 pm »
Brent , My XT is a 1980 model. But the coils are the same on all my XT's. Even have a complete US XT cdi setup it uses the same coil.  Yes I'm Curly from the XT forum.

Offline brent j

  • Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 1435
  • Darwin, NT. Suzuki tragic, RL250M TS90MX PE250B
    • View Profile
Re: Can I run an XT/TT coil with an SR CDI?
« Reply #6 on: April 29, 2009, 07:30:36 pm »
Sorry this has taken so long but a big thank you to all who replied.

I've got a new XT500 coil here and Curly, although it works and has given you no problems I'm not brave enough to try it. :-[
I'll make a new bracket and fit the SR coil I have so it will clear both tanks.

Col, thanks for taking the time to explain things. Electrics is something I've not had much to do with so the mind is starting to soak it up.

Cheers

Brent
The older I get, the faster I was